“The Meaning of Life” is a narrative achievement worthy of “Law & Order”‘s 25-year history. The show doesn’t always get things right, but last night’s episode had a great sequence of pacing, character development, and narrative surprises. The writers carefully crafted each scene, layering extremely complex and controversial themes involving fundamentalism (Islam and Christianity), reproductive freedom, and the literal meaning of life and death. Wow! Wow! Wow! The script was so masterfully executed that it dazzled me and resonated strongly with me and, I believe, with other viewers as well. Let’s get started.
Facts of the case: A middle-aged couple was walking and talking. The man, we learn, is named Christopher, a writer, professor, or both, who is called a “pagan” in his lectures. Given today’s political climate, his wife encouraged him to calm down. After returning home, he did not agree to limit the scholarship, but agreed to prepare dinner. His wife began to open the mail and shouted, “Do you know who sent this gift?” Suddenly, an improvised explosive device (IED) detonated. Dundon! An investigation begins.
“The Meaning of Life” – Law and Order, pictured: Reid Scott as Det. Vincent Riley.
We are learning more about Det. Riley, I’m a little conflicted about this. Why? Because in comparison, we know very little about Det. The background of Shaw is introduced. I may be missing something, but what else do we know about Shaw other than he was a lawyer before becoming a cop? He seemed to be a tall, healthy, handsome, moral police officer. While I can definitely accept this, I advocate for a fair and balanced portrayal of these officers. The show would improve if they added multiple dimensions to all the main characters, not just the detectives. Riley. But – back to the investigation.
Shaw and Riley discovered two key facts during their initial investigation at the hospital. Wife and fertility doctor Sarah is brain dead and her husband says it’s his fault. The husband admits his mistake and the detectives find the Muslim man (Ibrahim) who calls the husband a kafi. When Shaw and Riley arrived at Ibrahim’s apartment, he appeared to be building a bomb. But viewers know this is never their first detention. Home security cameras captured a second suspect transporting the bomb. Likewise, viewers know it’s rarely the second suspect they interrogate a perpetrator. This guy named Jason frequents shelters where victims volunteer. We learn that a white man paid him $100 to deliver a package. Jason is a drug addict with a long criminal record who is clearly only interested in the money, not the people who pay him – except for one detail. Jason thought the man’s name might be Jeremy or Jerry because he was wearing a bracelet that said Jer15.
“The Meaning of Life” – Law & Order, pictured: Michael Bahsil-Cook as Jason Barnwell.
As Shaw faded into the background, Detective Riley came to the forefront. Based on Shaw’s experience attending Catholic school, he speculated that Jer15 might represent Jeremiah 1:5 – “Before I formed you in the womb I knew you,” which he quoted verbatim. Granted, his beliefs are layered and nuanced. A clump of cells Then, Riley heroically saves another fertile son. Chat with a young woman named Teresa, who has a photo. When Patrick arrived at work, he attempted to escape, and he also captured a hostage and claimed to have a bomb.
Court: While the crime focused on the meaning of life at the outset, the DA must grapple with the meaning of life at the end. District attorneys including Baxter, Price and Maroun fiercely debated how to bring charges. Although Dr. Sarah met the neurological criteria for death, she was not legally dead. Therefore, Price believes the charge should be attempted murder. Sam thinks Dr. Sarah is dead. She is in an irreversible coma. She couldn’t breathe without the help of machines. Malone argued for first-degree murder due to the premeditated nature of the attack. Surprisingly, District Attorney Baxter agreed, saying, “The courts have been busy deciding when life begins. Let’s try to decide when life ends.”
“The Meaning of Life” – Law & Order, pictured: (left) Odelya Halevi as ADA Samantha Maroun and Hugh Dancy as ADA Nolan Price — (Photo by: Ralph Bavaro/NBC) © 2024 NBCUniversal Media, LLC
Clearly conflicted, Price went on to commit first-degree murder. During the trial, the case against Dr. Calhoun began to get murky when the defense called Dr. Calhoun to testify against the prosecution’s expert witness, who claimed that the chance of a brain-dead person waking up was 0.001 percent. Dr. Calhoun’s testimony cast doubt on the prosecution’s account, pointing to a phenomenon known as “Lazarus Syndrome,” in which people in an irreversible coma wake up inexplicably. Calhoun stressed that “only God knows” when life ends. At this juncture, District Attorney Baxter asserts, the case is no longer about science or medicine, but about emotion. (DNR) ) medical orders, if followed, would have made their case a success. Let her live. The next day, Sam informed Price that they had to present the new information to the judge in court. “Sarah took her last breath at 8:04 a.m.,” she said. Cut to the jury’s reading of the verdict: “We find the defendant guilty of first-degree murder.” Look, dunk.
Sam comforts Price, who is still conflicted about how things turned out, saying, “It’s a good day. We’re going to put the murderer behind bars for life.” How was your day today? The scene deftly balances the episode’s clear, pro-life message at the end of life with another message that shows that while there is still life in the body, there is meaning. There is hope. Only God knows.
The Meaning of Life – Law & Order, pictured: (left) Barry Coleman as Price’s father and Hugh Dancy as Ada Nolan Price. Photo: Ralph Bavaro/NBC © 2024 NBCUniversal Media, LLC
What do you think? Are you as moved by this heavy plot as I am? If so, please write to me. I’d love to chat about it.
Overall rating: